Skip to main content Skip to main navigation

Carl L. Withers Manuscript Collection

Call Number

RISM.MC.1

Date

1947-2005, inclusive

Creator

Withers, Carl

Extent

16.4 Linear Feet

Language of Materials

Materials are in English and Spanish.

Abstract

The Carl L. Withers Manuscript Collection documents the professional career of Carl L. Withers, including his experience as a professor of English, a book editor, anthropologist, and author of works exploring children's folklore. The collection primarily consists of material in English and Spanish that relates to extensive fieldwork studies conducted in various provinces of Cuba between 1947 and 1950. The collection includes correspondence, field notes, children's artwork, folklore, unpublished manuscripts, and an extensive range of black and white photographs. A portion of the collection relates to a research project on student life conducted at Yale University and a pilot study of American teen culture for the U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare.
Appended items to the collection include correspondence between Dr. Vera D. Rubin and Carl Withers, his bequest of the Cuban materials to Research Institute for the Study of Man (RISM), an unpublished memoir written by his friends, and books from his library.

Biographical Note

Carl Loraine Withers was born on March 20, 1900, the youngest of five children. His parents, Sarah Virginia Adams Withers and Horace Smith Withers, settled in a small rural community near Sheldon, Missouri. During his formative years, Withers' family experienced economic hardship. Nevertheless, in 1918 they managed to raise sufficient funds for Withers to travel to Harvard University where he successfuly passed the entrance exam and received conditional acceptance as an English major. For unknown reasons, Withers withdrew from Harvard a year later and for a brief period worked as a field-hand in Ely, Nevada. In 1920 he returned to Harvard to complete his studies and graduated magna cum laude in 1922.

Following graduation, Carl Withers was associated with various academic institutions. In 1923 he taught English at Northwestern University followed by a brief teaching assignment at the College of William and Mary. In 1925 Withers was appointed director of the English Department at Deerfield Academy. He left the position after receiving a fellowship from the Scandinavian-American Foundation at the University of Copenhagen. Over the next two years he traveled and studied in Europe. When he returned to the U.S. in January 1927, he held two part-time teaching positions at New York University (Washington Square College) and the Brooklyn Polytechnic Institute in Brooklyn, New York.

In 1929, Withers left academia to work as an editor for the Grolier Society in Kansas City, Kansas. This editorial position was the first of several positions he held with the company. While employed by Grolier, Withers acquired knowledge of anthropology through the influential works of A.L. Kroeber and Charles W. Wagley. In 1935 he enrolled in Columbia University's graduate anthropology program. Four years later he secured financial grants that enabled him to conduct a field study in Wheatland, Missouri. Following completion of the project in 1940, and prior to the publication of his findings, Withers resumed teaching at Brooklyn College. His findings were published in 1945 as Plainville, U.S.A. under the pseudonym James West.

In 1947 Withers returned to the Grolier Society's New York office as an editor-in-chief. His major accomplishment during this period was the publication of a ten-volume reference work Lands and Peoples, specifically created for young adults. Withers' second major accomplishment that year involved a successful proposal to conduct field studies in Cuba. Under the auspices of the Viking Fund and the American Philosophical Society, he traveled to Cuba in the summer of 1948, visiting both Mayajigua, Los Villas, situated on the north central coast of Cuba, and Trinidad, a city in central Cuba noted for its colonial architecture.

In the fall of 1948, Withers returned to the U.S. and accepted the position of Research Associate at Yale University's Department of Student Health. Working with Ralph Linton, his former graduate advisor at Columbia University, Withers organized studies focusing on the psychological stress experienced by undergraduates. The resulting publication, which Withers co-authored with Abram Kardiner, Ralph Linton, and Cora Du Bois, was published as Psychological Frontiers of Society.

Between 1949 and 1950, Withers returned to Mayajigua and expanded his field studies to include several other regions. He returned to the U.S. in 1950, intent on organizing the Cuban materials for publication. However, in 1952, a grant from the American International Association allowed him to travel to Venezuela, where he taught vocational skills in select schools for a year. In 1953 Withers accepted the position of visiting professor at the University of Brazil. While there, he conducted a field study of Arraial do Cabo, a coastal fishing village, as part of field work training for the employees of the National Museum of Brazil.

In 1956 Withers received a grant from the Research Institute for the Study of Man (RISM) to complete the Cuban manuscript, but after three years the work was still incomplete. In 1959 he accepted the position of Social Science Research Analyst at the Children's Bureau of the U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare (DHEW). In September 1960, with the financial support of DHEW and additional grants from the Ford Foundation and RISM, Withers launched a pilot study on American teen culture in St. Louis, Missouri. Through an arrangement with DHEW, Withers served as a visiting professor at Washington University in Missouri for the length of the study.

In the final years of his life, Carl Withers' long-standing interest in children's folklore dominated his time. His first book in the genre was the classic Rocket in My Pocket, published in 1948. By the mid-1960s 70,000 copies of the book had been sold.

In 1969 Withers' health began to decline, prompting his decision to transfer the Cuban materials to RISM. He died of a stroke in his Greenwich Village home on January 5, 1970.

Sources:

Jablow, Joseph. "Carl Withers." American Anthropologist. 74 (1973): 764-769.Hopkins, Frank Snowden. Carl Withers, A Memoir for his friends. August 1972 [unpublished manuscript]

Arrangement

The Carl L. Withers Collection has been organized chronologically within each series.

The collection is arranged is in the following series:

  1. I. Correspondence
  2. II. Notes on Cuba [Field Journals]
  3. III. Children's Artwork and Writings
  4. IV. Folklore Collection
  5. V. Photograph Collection
  6. VI. Unpublished Manuscripts
  7. VII. Studies in American Youth Culture
  8. VIII. Personal Writings
  9. IX. Oversized materials
  10. X. Material from Frank Snowden Hopkins
  11. XI. AV Materials (Material from Jorge Giovanetti)
  12. XII. Marcos A. Iglesias' Volumes on Yaguajay, Cuba
  13. Appendix

Scope and Contents

The Carl L. Withers Manuscript Collection chronicles Withers' fieldwork studies conducted in Cuba during the mid 20th century and includes correspondence, stenographic notebooks used for fieldwork entries, folklore, observations and research citations, print material, children's art work, poems and essays, unpublished manuscripts, photographs, maps, and ephemera.

Major strengths of the collection include more than 1,000 black and white photographs, which offer a rare portrait of Cuba during the pre-Castro era. Although Withers documented his 1948 visits to Mayajigua (Los Villas) and Trinidad, as well as subsequent visits in 1949 and 1950 to Havana, it remains unclear when he visited Baracoa, Santiago, Camaguey and other regions where photographs were taken.

There are also many challenges associated with the collection. Much of the correspondence is riddled with abbreviations and anthropological symbols, typical of Withers' handwriting. Many of the photographs lack identifying information. In addition, several of the photographs have been marred by Withers' handwritten notations.

Unpublished manuscripts include fragile and brittle papers that have been photocopied for research purposes.

The collection has benefited from a number of appended items that provide additional insight into Withers' life and particularly his working relationship with Dr. Vera D. Rubin and others. Culled from RISM's institutional files, these items include: 1) Withers' book proposal and outline for the Cuban study entitled The Green Island: Life in a Cuban Town, 2) select correspondence between Withers and Dr. Rubin concerning grants for the Cuban Study and the American Youth Culture Project, subsequently published as Plainville U.S.A., and a book review, 3) samples of a survey used to collect children's folklore, 4) Carl Withers' bequest to the Research Institute for the Study of Man, 5) a memoir written by Frank Snowden Hopkins, which includes Xeroxed images of Withers, 6) an obituary published in the American Anthropologist in 1972, and 7) posthumous correspondence related to Withers' Cuban materials.

Conditions Governing Access

Repository permission is required for access for some materials. Please contact New York University Archives, (212) 998-2641, university-archives@nyu.edu.

Conditions Governing Use

Any rights (including copyright and related rights to publicity and privacy) held by the creator are maintained by New York University. Permission to publish or reproduce materials in this collection must be secured from New York University Archives, (212) 998-2646, university-archives@nyu.edu.

Preferred Citation

Identification of item, date (if known); The Carl L. Withers Manuscript Collection; RISM MC 1; box number; folder number;
Research Institute for the Study of Man/New York University Archives

Location of Materials

Materials are stored offsite and advance notice is required for use. Please request materials at least two business days prior to your research visit to coordinate access.

Immediate Source of Acquisition

Materials were given to University Archives over several years by RISM, Withers, and others close to him.

Physical Characteristics and Technical Requirements

Due to the fragile nature of the original materials, researchers must use preservation copies of manuscripts in Series VI.

Separated Material

Envelopes with rare stamps have been separated from the collection and placed in the ALS/TLS section of the finding aid binder.

Books, journals, and other publications from the estate of Carl Withers, via the Research Institute for the Study of Man, were cataloged and are searchable in BobCat.

Related Material

The Sula Benet Papers, RISM RG 2.

Collection processed by

Emilyn L. Brown, Sep 2005. Inventory revised by John Bence and Margaret Fraser, Oct 2010. Series X processed by Catriona Schlosser.

About this Guide

This finding aid was produced using ArchivesSpace on 2023-08-20 17:56:16 -0400.
Using Describing Archives: A Content Standard
Language: Finding aid written in English.

Processing Information

Photographs were rehoused in archival folders and manuscript boxes; these top containers were renumbered in January 2019. Box #13 is no longer in use.

Processing information before 2019 has not been documented.

Revisions to this Guide

January 2019: Edited by Jacqueline Rider for compliance with DACS and ACM Required Elements for Archival Description

Edition of this Guide

This version was derived from Withers Finding Aid (rev).doc

Repository

New York University Archives
Research Institute for the Study of Man
New York University Archives
Elmer Holmes Bobst Library
70 Washington Square South
2nd Floor
New York, NY 10012